To the untrained eye, both auto reclosers and circuit breakers may seem like “switches,” but their functions, roles, and design philosophies are fundamentally different.
A circuit breaker is a protection device designed to automatically disconnect power in the event of electrical faults.
Fault interruption: When a short circuit, overload, or other fault occurs in the line, the relay detects the abnormal current and sends a trip command to the circuit breaker. The circuit breaker quickly operates, physically disconnecting the circuit, interrupting the fault current, and preventing equipment damage and the escalation of the accident. This is its most basic and important mission.
Isolation function: After disconnection, it forms a clear electrical break point, isolating the faulty section from the healthy power grid and ensuring the safety of maintenance personnel.
Auto recloser is specifically intended to restore power and assess fault types after a breaker trips.
Automatic restoration attempt: It does not directly interrupt the current but rather serves as a control system. When the circuit breaker trips due to a transient fault, the automatic reclosing device will automatically, with a delay, send a “closing” command to the circuit breaker according to a preset program, attempting to reconnect the circuit.
Intelligent judgment: If the fault is transient (such as lightning, wind contact with a wire, bird strike, etc.), the fault has disappeared, reclosing is successful, and power supply is restored, greatly improving power supply reliability. If the fault is permanent (such as a broken wire or equipment breakdown), the line will fail again, and the circuit breaker will trip again. In this case, the automatic reclosing will usually be “locked out” and will no longer issue a closing command, waiting for manual troubleshooting and repair.
Circuit Breaker:
Essence: A powerful mechanical switching device with strong arc-extinguishing capabilities (able to extinguish the arc generated when interrupting a large current).
Key Components: Arc-extinguishing chamber, contact system, operating mechanism, trip unit, etc.
Action: Upon receiving an electrical or mechanical signal indicating “trip” or “close,” its mechanism drives the contacts to physically open or close.
Automatic Reclosing:
Essence: An automated control device, typically integrated into a relay protection device or as a standalone unit.
Key Components: Microcontroller/microprocessor, timing logic circuit, counting element, interlocking logic, etc.
Action: It monitors the circuit breaker’s status (e.g., whether it has tripped), receives protection signals, and runs its built-in program logic to determine whether and when to issue a reclosing command.
Circuit breakers are ubiquitous, from power plants and substations to distribution networks and end-user distribution boxes, where reliable circuit disconnection is required.
Automatic reclosing is primarily used on overhead transmission and distribution lines. Because these lines are exposed to the elements, over 80% of faults are transient, caused by lightning strikes, tree contact, etc. Cable lines, due to their more permanent faults, are typically not equipped with reclosing devices.
Cooperation: On most overhead lines, the two work closely together. The output of the automatic reclosing device (or function) is directly connected to the closing circuit of the circuit breaker. The protection device controls tripping, while the reclosing device controls intelligent closing after a fault. Modern intelligent circuit breakers (such as vacuum circuit breakers and SF6 circuit breakers) are often integrated with digital protection devices that incorporate reclosing functionality.
| Feature | Circuit Breaker | Automatic Reclosing |
| Essence | Primary Equipment (Power Main Equipment) | Secondary Equipment (Control And Protection Equipment) |
| Function | Cut Off And Isolate Fault Current | Automatically Attempt To Restore Power Supply And Determine The Nature Of The Fault |
| Accent In Movement | Trip (Open), Close | Issue Reclosing Command Logic |
| Relationship | Execution Mechanism, Equivalent To “Hands” And “Knives” | Controlling The Brain Is Equivalent To Being A “Commander” And A “Decision-Maker” |
| Main Objective | Ensure System Security And Prevent Equipment Damage | Improve Power Supply Reliability And Reduce Power Outage Time |
| Fault Response | Make A Response To The Fault Once | Make Subsequent Intelligent Responses After Tripping |
Can we say that “circuit breakers are hardware, and automatic reclosing is software”?
The analogy is largely correct but not entirely accurate.
A more precise explanation: The circuit breaker is the actuator, and the automatic reclosing mechanism is the control strategy. Both transmit trip and close commands (software logic output) via secondary cables or fiber optics (hardware), together forming a complete “fault handling system.”
What are the typical automatic reclosing methods?
The reclosing method determines its level of “intelligence” and must be matched with the mechanical life and performance of the circuit breaker.
Three-phase single-phase reclosing: The most common method. Regardless of whether it’s a single-phase or multi-phase fault, all three phases trip and then reclose simultaneously. Suitable for most medium and low voltage lines, and matched with ordinary three-phase operating circuit breakers.
Single-phase automatic reclosing: Used for high-voltage/ultra-high-voltage transmission lines. When a single-phase ground fault occurs, only the faulty phase circuit breaker trips, and then that phase recloses. This requires the circuit breaker to have phase-by-phase operation capability (e.g., each phase has an independent mechanism). High success rate and minimal impact on system stability.
Differences in maintenance and testing of circuit breakers and auto recloser
Circuit breaker maintenance focus (emphasizing “mechanical and insulation”):
Mechanical characteristics: Opening and closing time, speed, synchronicity, bounce, and mechanism lubrication.
Arc extinguishing medium: SF6 gas pressure/purity, vacuum bubble vacuum level.
Electrical insulation: Insulation resistance between contacts and to ground, withstand voltage level.
Conductive circuit: Main contact contact resistance and heating status.
Automatic reclosing maintenance focus (emphasizing “logic and settings”):
Logic function testing: Simulate transient/permanent faults to verify the correctness of the entire logic sequence of “start-delay-closing command-acceleration after reclosing-locking”.
Setting verification: Verify that the reclosing delay, reclosing count, and other settings are consistent with the settings issued by the dispatching department.
Signal circuit verification: Ensure that it can correctly receive circuit breaker position signals and protection action signals, and correctly issue closing commands.
Coordination test with protection devices: Ensure that functions such as reclosing and post-acceleration protection work together correctly.
Circuit breakers are responsible for decisively cutting off danger in critical moments; automatic reclosing, on the other hand, enhances the resilience of the power grid and the user experience, giving circuit breakers a “cautious remedial opportunity.”
Circuit breakers and automatic reclosing, working together, minimize unnecessary power outages while ensuring safety, jointly forming the foundation for the safe, reliable, and efficient operation of modern power systems. Understanding their differences helps us better understand the intricate protection logic behind complex power systems.
Optimized by Seraphinite Accelerator
